The Most Fun We Ever Had

The Most Fun We Ever Had

A Novel

Book - 2019
Average Rating:
Rate this:
"A multi-generational novel in which the four adult daughters of a Chicago couple--still madly in love after forty years--match wits, harbor grudges, and recklessly ignite old rivalries until a long-buried secret threatens to shatter the lives they've built"-- Provided by publisher.
Publisher: New York : Doubleday, [2019]
Edition: First edition
Copyright Date: ©2019
ISBN: 9780385544252
Characteristics: 537 pages ; 25 cm


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Feb 10, 2021

Modern Mrs Darcy

Sep 26, 2020

This book was kind of interesting, well written but riddled with bad people. I guess read this if you like reading about dysfunctional families who treat each other terribly? The grandparents Marilyn and David are pretty likeable people, but their children are all completely awful. I think there's always this drive to make characters 'realistic' by giving them flaws, but it seemed so extreme to read about. The two eldest daughters are especially difficult to read. Their words and actions were consistently filled with animosity. Wendy is mean spirited after serious tragedy in her life. She lashed out at everyone around her, and the author seems to justify it by explaining that she was a horrible shitty person even before she experienced all the tragedy. Violet is just a vile human being obsessed with her own self image. Her husband was portrayed pretty negatively, but there were a lot of moments when he was in the right simply because she was so horrible. Her children are the sweetest despite the fact that their parents seem to dislike everything else about their lives. Matt (the husband) has some redeeming moments when he stands up for Jonah after realizing that his wife has been unreasonably cruel to him. Liza would rather cheat on her boyfriend than rightfully break up with him. Ryan (the boyfriend) deserved better from the situation, and she had no idea how to help him without just coddling him. It's the typical situation of a grown adult woman believing that her love will somehow make up for their clear incompatibility and his need for professional help with his clinical depression. Grace is a liar who seriously can't get her life together. I think the author tried to excuse it because she was a lost millennial/genz child trying to find herself after college. I get that it's a difficult period in ones life, but lying to your parents who clearly love and support you is completely ridiculous. It also made absolutely no sense why the perfectly lovely Ben would have any interest in her overwhelming low self-esteem. The grandchildren are the only decent human beings in the family apart from the grandparents. I rooted for Jonah the whole time, and he was what kept me reading. The author seemed really caught on this idea that because Marilyn and David loved each other so much, they didn't have enough love for their children. It was preposterous.

Mar 07, 2020

As one who reads 99% non-fiction I felt almost embarassed to be carrying this novel around but something about the book's attractive cover and the words inside kept me plowing through to the end, embarrassment be damned. This is a light read (aside from the number of pages), almost an old-fashioned novel of a family with grown children. Nothing really happens but neither does it make for unpleasant reading. The characters and family are ones I enjoyed being around for a while. Now back to the non-fiction...

Nov 24, 2019

Enjoyable read. The novel centres around the relationships between the Sorensen family members: the parents, the 4 daughters, and ancillary characters. It jumps back and forth between when the parents were just meeting and raising their family in the 70s, to the early 2000s, when the daughters are all adults with lives of their own. As a non-parent, I found a few of the sections got a bit lengthy on details around pregnancies, birth and child rearing -- but overall the drama between the characters was engaging.

Nov 05, 2019

The Most Fun We Ever Had is the story of a Chicago family of 4 sisters, Wendy, Violet, Liza, and Grace, over the course of 1 year. Interwoven into that story is the story of their past beginning with how their parents met. The sisters experience highs and lows and the revelation of a secret adoption 15 years ago and the introduction of that child to the family. It is part salacious fun and part typical family saga and very white.

This book was 4 stars for fun and maybe a bit less for writing. It seemed longer than it needed to be, and that's not just because we are all used to instant gratification. I am impressed with Lombardo's ability to keep a lot of plates spinning in the air though. I would recommend this book to people who like dysfunctional family stories, sister stories, and a bit of humor in their novels and aren't intimidated by 500 pages. I listened to this on audio, and Emily Rankin did a great job with the material.

IndyPL_LindsayH Oct 29, 2019

This book is unusual because it tells the story of a seemingly perfect marriage, but at the same time it is a tale of a dysfunctional family. Marilyn and David have been married for forty years and are still madly in love with each other. Their four adult daughters have not found the same idyllic happiness that their parents have. If you like family sagas this novel will hook you from the beginning to the end.

Oct 21, 2019

This was unnecessarily long, but still kept me turning the pages. I've read that a TV show is in the works...

Sep 12, 2019

Meh. Could not finish although I wanted to, but when reading feels like a job, best to stop reading the book. Better books out there with complex family dynamics to sink my teeth into.

Aug 20, 2019

I enjoyed this book. As one of four sisters myself, I deeply appreciate how accurately Lombardo writes about the intricacies of sisterhood. She didn't gloss it over. The jealousy, the betrayals, the competition, but also, if you're lucky, the very real love. In the midst of an argument, my sister once told me, "It's not like we're Little Women". At the time it broke my heart. But over the years, I've come to appreciate her viewpoint and the reality of our complicated love for each other. No, we're not Little Women. But we have our moments. I enjoyed reading an honest reflection of what that looks like...the good, the bad, the ugly, all of it. Family.

Aug 10, 2019

Today I got to hear Claire Lombardo read a passage of her book before leading our book discussion. Thank you, Library Lovers! It was a treat and a memorable experience. I did love spending time with the Sorenson family for the most part and appreciated the character development as well as the complex structure of the book. My favorite "character" was the beloved ginkgo tree that was a mainstay in so many major family moments --its leaves featured on the cover. Unfortunately, for me the language was a bit too crass at times. We just do not regularly drop the f-bomb in casual conversation and neither do our friends. Perhaps we are just not "with it," but I was turned off by this aspect of the book.


Add a Summary
JCLSallyK Mar 31, 2020

This book jumps around in time quite a bit. I was really anticipating enjoying this book but found it rather flat. The one element of the book I did find relatable was the siblings relationships and how much they reminded me of my own sibling relationships.


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at GRPL

To Top